Sharing is caring!

How to strengthen sourdough starter for better bread baking. Learn tips to boost starter maturity and activity for perfect, pouffy loaves.

I first tried making my own sourdough starter 3+ years ago. While making my own starter was a success, the bread I was baking with it was not. I couldn’t figure out why my bread was turning out flat, even though I was following the recipe to the T. Years later, I found out about the importance of starter strength and maturity. If you don’t have a healthy sourdough starter that is mature and active, your bread baking won’t be very successful. Or perhaps one of the other factors is off: be it temperature, feeing rations or using water with chlorine in it. In this post I will share all I know about how to strengthen sourdough starter so that you too can bake wonderfully pouffy loaves of sourdough bread. 

This article may contain affiliate links, which means I make a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. You can read the full disclosure policy.

How strengthening the starter will help your sourdough

• having a stronger sourdough starter will mean more activity which in turn means airier, puffier & more delicious sourdough bread. This is the key to baking delicious homemade sourdough that gets significant rise every time. 
• to strengthen a sourdough starter is not difficult – with a few simple tips, this can fix things up very fast 
• even if you try all of the techniques and you have a healthy starter but your bread is still turning out flat, you probably don’t have a mature starter – more on that below

Ingredients 

• active sourdough starter
• all purpose flour 
• filtered water 

Tools

• kitchen scale 

Instructions

1. If your sourdough starter was in the fridge, take it out and discard about 80% of it. Save your discard in a jar and place back in the fridge for later use.  
2. Place the jar with the little bit of satrert left at the bottom on the kitchen scale and press Tare 
3. Add equal parts of flour and water. The amounts here depend on the size of your jar and the amount of sourdough stater you need. I usually add 100g flour and 100g water. 
4. Stir very well. The consistency should not be too runny but also not too firm. 
5. Cover with a tea towel, secure with a rubber band and place on your kitchen counter or in a proofing box. 
6. About about 10-12 hours later, repeat the process. 
7. Keep repeating until your starter doubles or triples between feedings and has larger bubbles forming on the inside 

FAQ

I tried all of this, and my starter is still not rising. 

A couple of different things might be happening here. Your starter might be kept in cooler temperatures that inhibit the whole process. If so, the rise is going to take much longer. You could place it in your cold oven with the pilet light on, but be so careful not to accidentally bake your starter (I’ve done this many times). You could also place it inside your instant pot with warm water around it. However the method that works the best by far, is using a proofing box. Nothing else will do the trick quite like that. 

If your starter is warm enough but not rising, continue feeding it at regular intervals for about a week. If it’s still sluggish, try substituting whole wheat flour, or fresh flour (freshly milled). Your starter will love that, and should rise much better & faster than with regular white flour. 

My starter is rising, but my bread is still coming out flat. 

Once again, several different things might be happening here. Your recipe might be off, you might be letting your bread proof for too long or too little. But presuming all of those things are working well, and you have a new sourdough starter, then I would guess that it’s not mature enough. In order to mature sourdough starter, you simply feed it at regular intervals over a longer period of time (about a month for my last starter). You can use the discard to make all sorts of sourdough discard recipes until you have a ripe starter that is ready to make an amazing loaf of bread. Some of my favorite things to make with sourdough discard: Sourdough Granola, Sourdough Oatmeal Cookies and Sourdough Crepes.

Can I use tap water for my starter?

Tap water is often fine, but if it contains a lot of chlorine or chloramine, it can inhibit yeast growth. If your starter isn’t performing well, try using filtered or bottled water.

How can I tell if my starter is active and strong enough to bake with?

A strong starter should double in volume within 4-6 hours of feeding, show lots of bubbles, and have a pleasant, slightly tangy aroma. It should pass the “float test” — a spoonful of starter should float in water.

Can I revive a neglected starter?

Yes, you can often revive a neglected starter. Remove most of the starter, keeping about a tablespoon, and start feeding it with equal parts flour and water twice a day until it becomes active again.

Why does my starter have mold on it?

Mold can develop if the starter is neglected for too long or kept in unsanitary conditions. Discard any starter with visible mold, clean the container thoroughly, and start a new batch using a small, uncontaminated portion of the starter if possible.

What should I do if my starter smells bad?

If your starter smells off (e.g., like cheese, feet, or rotten), it might be contaminated. Discard most of it, keep a small portion, and feed it with fresh flour and water. Ensure your feeding containers are clean and use filtered water.

Can temperature affect my starter’s strength?

Yes, temperature plays a crucial role. Starters thrive at warm temperatures between 70-75°F (21-24°C). If it’s too cold, the yeast will be sluggish; if it’s too hot, it can grow too fast and exhaust its food supply quickly.

Tips

1. Increase Feeding Frequency:

• Feed your starter more frequently, ideally every 10 – 12 hours, to ensure it has a consistent supply of nutrients. This encourages active fermentation and growth.

2. Use Whole Grain Flours:

• Incorporate whole grain flours like whole wheat or whole grain rye flour into your feedings. This type of flour is richer in nutrients and wild yeast, which can boost the activity of your starter.

3. Maintain Optimal Temperature:

• Keep your starter in a warm spot, ideally in an ambient temperature between 70-75°F (21-24°C). Yeast and bacteria are more active at these temperatures, leading a faster fermentation process and a stronger starter.

4. Use Filtered or Dechlorinated Water:

• Chlorine and chloramine in tap water can inhibit the growth of your starter. Use filtered or dechlorinated water to avoid this issue.

5. Keep a Consistent Feeding Ratio:

• A common feeding ratio is 1:1:1 (starter:water by weight). Maintaining consistent ratios helps ensure balanced growth.

6. Ensure Proper Hydration:

• A 100% hydration starter (equal parts water and flour by weight) is common, but adjusting to a slightly lower hydration can sometimes help strengthen a sluggish starter.

7. Discard Before Feeding:

• Always discard a portion of your starter before feeding. This keeps the acid and alcohol levels in check and ensures the remaining starter has enough food.

8. Stir the Starter:

• Stirring the starter between feedings can help incorporate oxygen, which is beneficial for the yeast and bacteria.

9. Use Clean Containers:

• Make sure you use a clean jar for your sourdough starter. Contaminants can hinder the growth of beneficial microbes.

10. Be Patient:

• Sometimes, starters need time to become fully active. Be patient and consistent with your feedings, and your starter should strengthen over time.

11. Monitor for Signs of Activity:

• Look for signs like bubbles, rising and falling, and a pleasant, tangy smell. These are indicators that your starter is active and healthy.

12. Adjust Feeding Amounts:

• If your starter is very active, you might need to increase the amount of flour and water you feed it to keep up with the fermentation activity.

13. Create a Warm Environment:

• If your kitchen is cold, consider placing your starter in a warmer spot, such as near a warm appliance or using a proofing box.

14. Use a Different Flour Blend:

• Experiment with different blends of flours. Sometimes a combination of flours can provide a better nutrient profile for your starter.

15. Test with the Float Test:

• To check if your starter is ready for baking, perform the float test: drop a small spoonful of starter into water. If it floats, it’s ready to use.

Troubleshooting Tips

• If Your Starter is Inactive: Try feeding it more frequently, using whole grain flours, and ensuring it’s kept in a warm environment.
• If Your Starter Smells Off: It might need more frequent feedings or fresher flour. Discard most of it and feed it with fresh flour and water.
• If You See Hooch: This is a sign your starter is hungry. Pour off the hooch and feed the starter more frequently.
• If Your Starter Has Mold: Discard any starter with mold, clean the container thoroughly, and start a new batch if necessary.

Storage

Refrigeration:

• Short-Term Storage:If you plan to use your starter within a week, refrigeration is a good option.
  • Feed the Starter: Feed your starter as usual and let it sit at room temperature for 2-3 hours.
  • Refrigerate: Cover the container loosely to allow some airflow and place it in the refrigerator.
  • Maintenance: Feed the starter once a week. Take it out, discard most of it, feed it, let it sit at room temperature for a few hours, and then return it to the fridge.

Freezing:

• Long-Term Storage:Freezing can preserve your starter for several months.
  • Prepare the Starter: Feed your starter and let it become active. Allow it to sit at room temperature until it doubles in size.
  • Divide and Freeze: Divide the starter into small portions (e.g., 1/4 cup). Place each portion in a small, airtight container or a freezer bag.
  • Label and Freeze: Label the containers with the date and freeze them.
  • Reviving: To use the frozen starter, thaw it in the refrigerator overnight. Feed it with equal parts flour and water, and let it sit at room temperature. You may need to feed it several times to fully revive it.

Freeze-Drying:

• Long-Term Storage:Freeze-drying is an effective method for preserving a starter for an extended period.
  • Prepare the Starter: Feed and activate your starter as usual.
  • Dry the Starter: Spread a thin layer of the starter on a parchment-lined baking sheet. Allow it to air dry at room temperature or use a dehydrator on the lowest setting. This can take several days.
  • Break into Pieces: Once completely dry, break the starter into small pieces or grind it into a powder.
  • Store: Place the dried starter in an airtight container or vacuum-sealed bag. Store it in a cool, dark place.
  • Reviving: To revive, rehydrate the dried starter with an equal amount of water. Let it sit for several hours, then feed it with flour and water. It may take a few feedings to fully reactivate.

Tips for Storing and Reviving

• Clean Containers: Always use clean, sanitized containers to prevent contamination.
• Labeling: Label containers with dates and any specific details to keep track of storage times.
• Patience in Revival: When reviving stored starter, be patient. It might take a few feedings for the starter to regain full activity.
• Regular Feeding Schedule: Maintain a regular feeding schedule for refrigerated starters to keep them healthy.

More Recipes Like This You’ll Enjoy

• How to make any yeast recipe with sourdough starter
• Best Way to Toast Sourdough Bread {Easy Recipe}
• How to proof sourdough bread in the fridge overnight